Does anesthesia change how vets grade hip dysplasia in dogs

Abstract

This study aimed to evaluate the effect of anesthesia on grading of canine hip dysplasia. For this purpose, 20 middle-sized healthy dogs from different breeds were used. Radiographs were taken using 4 different imaging methods, including the hip-extended, subluxation, distraction, and compression. This procedure was repeated 4 times for each dog, while the dogs were unanesthetized and anesthetized with 3 different anesthetic protocols at 15-day intervals (propofol [5 mg/kg, IV]; diazepam [0.5 mg/kg, IV] / ketamine [20 mg/kg, IV]; medetomidine [0.05 &#x3bc;g/kg, IM] / ketamine [20 mg/kg, IM]). The radiographs were taken and evaluated by the same investigator to prevent interobserver variation. Because of the radiographic positioning difficulty, unanesthetized radiographic imaging revealed higher repetition number than the anesthetized; therefore, radiation safety decreased. The administration of diazepam/ketamine and medetomidine/ketamine was sufficient in terms of both muscle relaxation and duration of the anesthesia; however, some dogs under propofol anesthesia were required maintenance doses to complete radiographic imaging procedure. Unanesthetized radiographic images of the dogs had significantly lower (P < .001) hip score, distraction index (DI), subluxation index (SI), and higher compression index (CI) (P< .001), when compared with anesthetized radiographic images. When compared the anesthetic protocols, propofol revealed lower (P< 0.001) hip score, DI, SI, and higher (P < .001) CI than medetomidine/ketamine. Medetomidine/ketamine is the most appropriate anesthetic protocol for detailed radiographic evaluation of CHD considering both muscle relaxation and duration of action.